{
  "schema_version": "circle-ai-panel-review-frame-v1",
  "updated_at": "2026-05-23",
  "name": "The AI Panel Review Frame",
  "canonical_url": "https://circlethepeople.com/ai-panel/",
  "machine_readable_url": "https://circlethepeople.com/ai/model-review-frame.json",
  "reviews_json_url": "https://circlethepeople.com/ai-panel/reviews.json",
  "purpose": "A transparent product-inspection frame for asking AI models to evaluate Circle the People products using the same questions and public product information.",
  "disclosure": "AI model reviews are generated evaluations based on the product information and prompt shown here. They are not independent human endorsements.",
  "prompt_preamble": [
    "You are reviewing a software product.",
    "Your job is to evaluate the product in plain English for a business owner, operations leader, parent, household, writer, or team manager who is trying to understand whether the tool solves a real problem.",
    "Do not write a sales pitch.",
    "If the product is especially compelling, explain why in practical terms instead of using hype.",
    "Use only the product information provided.",
    "Be specific, honest, and useful."
  ],
  "questions": [
    "What problem does this product solve?",
    "Who is the product for?",
    "What old or broken workflow does it replace?",
    "What are the product's strongest features?",
    "What makes the product useful in real-world, high-pressure, or accountability-heavy environments?",
    "What are the main benefits for a company, household, parent, writer, or team?",
    "What risks, limitations, or adoption challenges should be considered?",
    "What makes this product different from a basic app, spreadsheet, email thread, note, or messaging tool?",
    "What would make the product stronger?",
    "In one plain-English paragraph, why does this product matter?"
  ],
  "rating_labels": [
    "Strong",
    "Moderate",
    "Needs More Proof",
    "Unclear"
  ],
  "rating_categories": [
    "problem_clarity",
    "workflow_value",
    "accountability_or_record_value",
    "ease_of_understanding",
    "differentiation",
    "adoption_challenge",
    "best_fit_user_clarity"
  ],
  "required_public_metadata": [
    "model used",
    "date reviewed",
    "prompt used",
    "product information provided",
    "ChatGPT reference review when used for orientation",
    "raw or lightly formatted model response",
    "human summary when present, clearly labeled"
  ],
  "reference_review_policy": "ChatGPT/OpenAI may be used as the first reference review. Other models may receive that reference for orientation, but they are instructed to give their own independent review rather than simply agreeing with it.",
  "products_to_review": [
    {
      "product_key": "anchor",
      "name": "Anchor",
      "canonical_url": "https://circlethepeople.com/anchor/",
      "summary": "Anchor helps households make proof before they need it: a printable home inventory with photos, serial numbers, descriptions, owner attestation, and replacement value totals for moves, storms, claims, storage, and cleanup.",
      "product_summary_json": "https://circlethepeople.com/ai/anchor-summary.json"
    },
    {
      "product_key": "finch",
      "name": "Finch",
      "canonical_url": "https://circlethepeople.com/finch/",
      "summary": "Finch helps people say it better before they send it by turning rough texts, emails, captions, comments, passive-aggressive replies, and awkward drafts into the version they meant to send.",
      "product_summary_json": "https://circlethepeople.com/ai/finch-summary.json"
    },
    {
      "product_key": "sayit",
      "name": "SayIt",
      "canonical_url": "https://circlethepeople.com/sayit/",
      "summary": "SayIt helps people practice the hard thing first by turning rough thoughts into calmer words for boundaries, apologies, family moments, work pressure, and out-loud rehearsal.",
      "product_summary_json": "https://circlethepeople.com/ai/sayit-summary.json"
    },
    {
      "product_key": "spotter",
      "name": "Spotter",
      "canonical_url": "https://circlethepeople.com/spotter/",
      "summary": "Spotter helps parents turn concern into a clear dated record for behavior changes, school issues, bullying concerns, online pressure, local help contacts, and parent-owned follow-up.",
      "product_summary_json": "https://circlethepeople.com/ai/spotter-summary.json"
    },
    {
      "product_key": "jrnl",
      "name": "jRNL",
      "canonical_url": "https://circlethepeople.com/jrnl/",
      "summary": "jRNL is a private place to write down what happened before the story changes shape, sort emotional fog, protect memory, and find a clearer next step.",
      "product_summary_json": "https://circlethepeople.com/ai/jrnl-summary.json"
    },
    {
      "product_key": "query_quick",
      "name": "Query Quick",
      "canonical_url": "https://circlethepeople.com/query-quick/",
      "summary": "Query Quick helps writers stop spending an hour researching one agent by compressing agent status, genre fit, guidelines, forms, QueryManager links, and submission requirements into a clean submission-ready workflow.",
      "product_summary_json": "https://circlethepeople.com/ai/query-quick-summary.json"
    }
  ]
}